I'm looking for a song that's a remake of Over My Head by the Fray. It goes to the tune of Over My Head, but has a strong beat and a guy that sounds kind of bubblegum pop-ish. It goes something like this:
You were my first girl
But you've always been my favorite girl
I just broke up with my latest girl
Maybe you could be my latest girl
Everybody knows I'm still not over you

Then he talks about her being his first girl and that she could be his last girl. About writing love notes in seventh grade and that they could pretend it was 2000. Anyone know it?